Skip to main content

4 Beds

4 Full baths

3,801 SqFt

Active

This storied waterfront estate occupies a 1.24-acre lot within the largest contiguous parcel on the Gulf Coast, a magnificent private park with a majestic landscape and vistas on par with Selby Gardens and the grounds of the nearby Ringling Museum. Renowned for its historical significance and stately Southern Colonial architecture, the Earle House presents a rare restoration opportunity to customize modern luxury with the provenance and style of old-world elegance. Encompassing both a two-story primary home and separate garage and guest house, the estate offers spacious accommodations for enjoyment as a seasonal retreat or year-round residence. Priced with consideration for renovations, this property is both comfortably livable and poised for thorough personalization. Distinguished by a double-height colonnade and beautiful brick exterior, the 4-bedroom, 4.5-bathroom home boasts original classical features throughout, including wood paneling and crown moulding, hardwood floors, fluted balusters, gas fireplaces, large chandeliers, stained glass transom, double-hung windows, and French doors. Built in 1927 and renovated to modern standards in the 90s with additional projects in following years, the home’s upgrades include a waterfront saltwater pool, elevator, walk-in showers, and top-line appliances. Flanked by leaded glass window panels, the south-facing main entry opens to a grand foyer that leads on one side to the dining room and on the other to the waterfront great room and adjoining solarium. Awash in natural light from both south- and north-facing windows, the great room is anchored by a large central fireplace with granite hearth and an ornately carved mantle, with access at one end to a private wood-clad den with powder bath. Subtly partitioned from the great room by a coffered beam, the adjacent solarium seamlessly extends the main living space and spectacular vistas with a surround of oversized windows and double doors that open to the pool terrace and waterfront lawn. On the east side of the main floor, the foyer opens to the spacious dining room with two original arched door corner cupboards and a well-appointed wet bar that adds ample storage as well as additional under-counter refrigeration and dedicated beverage cooler. Beyond the dining room, a breakfast nook opens to the roomy kitchen. Upstairs, a spacious landing leads to three large bedrooms, each with incredible views. To the right, a private alcove with elevator access leads to the western-facing primary suite with a massive brightly lit bedroom, walk-in closet with custom built-in wardrobe system, and a marble-clad bathroom with oversized vanity and walk-in shower. On the other side of the landing, two additional bedrooms offer generous layouts. The history of the Earle House is integral to Sarasota’s early 20th-century development, dating to the formation of the Indian Beach community with the sale of magnificent waterfront homes to affluent families from across the United States. This remarkable estate, enviably near the Ringling Museum and Asolo Theatre, stands on an indescribable piece of land with more than 130 feet of private waterfront, winding paths, and a palm grove complementing the lush tropical landscape. With adjacent parcels available by separate offer, this is an opportunity to acquire the largest acreage on the Gulf Coast, rich in architectural history and unmatched in natural beauty.

Property Details
Price $3,500,000
Bedrooms 4
Full Baths 4
Half Baths 1
Property Style Colonial
Lot Size Area 1.2383
Lot Size Area Units Acres
Acres 1.2
Property Type Residential
Sub type SingleFamilyResidence
MLS Sub type Single Family Residence
Features Built-in Features, Ceiling Fan(s), Crown Molding, Elevator, PrimaryBedroom Upstairs, Solid Surface Counters, Solid Wood Cabinets, Walk-In Closet(s), Wet Bar
Exterior Features French Doors, Irrigation System, Lighting
Year Built 1929
Subdivision INDIAN BEACH MAP OF
View Water
Roof Shingle
Waterfront SARASOTA BAY
Heating Central, Electric
Foundation Slab
Lot Description FloodZone
Laundry Features Laundry Room
Pool features In Ground
Parking Description Circular Driveway, Driveway
Garage spaces 2
Geographic Data
Directions From N Tamiami Trail, turn west on Myrtle St. Turn Right on Bay Shore Rd. Property will be on the left.
County Sarasota
Latitude 27.373284
Longitude -82.56201
Market Area 34234 - Sarasota
Address Information
Address 4521 BAY SHORE ROAD, SARASOTA, FL 34234
Postal Code 34234
City SARASOTA
State FL
Country United States
Listing Information
Listing Office DOUGLAS ELLIMAN
Listing Office Phone 941-867-6199
Listing Agent Lisa Morris
Listing Agent Phone 941-544-3332
Special listing conditions None
Ownership Fee Simple
Terms Cash, Conventional
Virtual Tour URL https://tours.coastalhomephotography.net/2246896?idx=1
School Information
Elementary School Emma E. Booker Elementary
Middle School Booker Middle
High School Booker High
MLS Information
Days on market 307
MLS Status Active
Listing Date Jun 5, 2024
Listing Last Modified May 13, 2025
Tax ID 2004040002
Tax Year 2024
Tax Annual Amount 63666
MLS Area 34234 - Sarasota
MLS # A4611837

Map View


This information was updated 2025-05-23T05:43:20.150101Z